Why "It Depends" Defines Financial Planning
One phrase the Director of Virginia Tech’s Financial Planning and Wealth Management program frequently used when discussing client recommendations was, “It depends.” As a student, this could be quite frustrating when studying for a multiple-choice exam. However, “it depends” is precisely what makes financial planning meaningful and engaging.
Financial Planning involves looking at a client’s entire financial picture and advising them on how to achieve their short and long-term financial goals. Every client brings a unique set of values, resources, risk tolerance, and aspirations. Because of this, understanding a client begins with far more than their balance sheet or cash‑flow statement. For example, a client hoping to purchase a home within a few years may need a more conservative investment allocation to protect the funds required for a down payment. The recommendations should reflect not just financial data, but the client’s goals.
Perhaps the most important element of the advisor–client relationship is its ongoing nature. Both external and personal circumstances change over time.
Economic and legislative shifts, such as market volatility or updates to tax laws, can directly influence a client’s financial picture. Returning to the home‑purchase example, a change in interest rates could affect housing affordability. The advisor should work with the client to understand if the recommendation should be modified.
At the same time, clients’ lives change. Events like having a child, the passing of a loved one, or shifting personal priorities often require updates to their financial, tax, estate, insurance, and investment strategies. A strong advisor–client relationship helps the advisor stay informed about these meaningful life events, gather deeper insights, and continually refine recommendations.
In short, what makes financial planning impactful is its ability to adapt to each client’s needs and goals. The answer may often be “it depends.” Although, with a holistic understanding of a client’s life and ongoing communication, that answer becomes the foundation for tailored, effective, and evolving financial advice.